Showing posts with label Sanhedrin. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sanhedrin. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Sanhedrin 30a

What is the legal distinction between "Eidim" and "Beis Din"?  They are two distinct legal categories.  I have said many times that Halacha sees Eidim as being more than just "witnesses". Eidim are in a way "Officers of the Court", acting together as  "Notaries Public" who validate proceedings with their testimony.  The Torah uses the expression "Two or three eidim", so there is such a thing as a triad of eidim.

But a Beis-Din, the Court itself, has a power above and beyond that of the Legal Force of the Eidim.  What is the nature of this difference?

Why is a statement made in front of people acting as witnesses more impeachable than a statement made in front of a Beis Din.

Why does the number three mean so much more than the number two? To strengthen the point, I will point out that the Gemara itself presents a view that a Beis Din of two has standing according to Shmuel.  Yet there is seemingly still an advantage in a Beis Din of two members (Beis Din Chatzuf) over an eidim team of three!  Why?